BOOK REVIEW
Name of the Book: Woman in Islamic
Shariah
Author: Maulana Wahiduddin Khan
Pages: 160
ISBN: 9788187570318
Reviewed by: Mr Tauseef Ahmad
Parray
Regarding women and Islam, the
author, Maulana Wahiduddin Khan has
three significant books to his credit:
Women between Islam and Western
Society, Woman in Islamic Shariah and
Women: The Builders of Humankind as
well as many booklets such as Polygamy
and Islam, Concerning Divorce and Hijab
in Islam.
Women in Islamic Shariah consists of eleven chapters that discuss the
status of women in Islam in the light of the teachings of the Quran
and Sunnah, womanhood in Islam, the qualities of Muslim women, the
rights and duties of the husband and wife in the first five chapters., The
remaining chapters offer a detailed discussion of concepts and issues
relating to divorce, polygamy, dowry, hijab, etc., in light of Islamic
teachings and history. The book concludes with a chapter on “success
in marriage”.
In his ‘Foreword’, the author quotes the statement of Edward William
Lane (Selections from Kuran, London, 1982, p. xc) that ‘the fatal blot
in Islam is the degradation of women”. For Khan, this ‘ill-considered
observation gained such currency’ in the succeeding centuries that
instead of having ‘elapsed since then’, it has so ‘deepened’ as ‘if it were
an established fact’ (p. 11 ). Against this backdrop, he asserts that ‘to
interpret the Islamic concept of womanhood as a ‘degradation’ of
women is to distort the actual issue. Islam has never asserted that
women are inferior to men: it has only made the point that ‘women
are differently constituted’ (Ibid.). This is precisely the main theme and
thesis of this book.
Quoting many Quranic verses (like 2: 228; 3: 195 ; 4: 7 , 19, 124 ; 9: 71 ; 16:
97 ; 30: 21 ; 40: 40 ) as well as sayings of the Prophet Muhammad related
to women, Khan, in chapter 1, “Quran and Hadith”, affirms that both
foundational sources of Islam ‘give detailed commandments regarding
women, and also lay down clear guidelines for the relationship between
men and women’ and they also ‘highlight the most important aspects of
feminine virtues and the standing which a woman should have vis-à-vis
her husband and father’ (p. 15 ). In the second chapter, “The qualities
of a believing woman”, he refers to the ‘basic attributes of men and
women’ as depicted in Quran 33: 35 . These are Islam, Iman (faith),
Qunut (sincere obedience to God), Sidq (truthfulness), Sabr (patience),
Khushu (apprehension, fear), Sadaqah (charity), Sawm (fasting), Ihsan
(chastity), Dhikr (remembrance of God), and Tawbah (repentance),
Ibadah (worship) and Siyahah (itinerancy), respectively (pp. 21 – 24 ).
These qualities, taken together ‘constitute an ideal, not just for men,
but for both sexes’, and they ‘form the basis of Islam’ as well (p. 25 ).
In this chapter, he further asserts that as “men function on different
planes of religiosity, so do women have their own separate spheres
of religious effectiveness”; and besides the domestic sphere, it is
possible for a “talented woman to further the cause of religion when
the right opportunity presents itself” (pp. 25 , 26 ). In this case, he cites
the examples of Aishah, wife of the Prophet Muhammad and the
daughter of Imam Abu Jafar al-Tahawi, and their contribution to sacred
knowledge showing ‘the nature and extent of the contribution which
can be made by believing Muslim women to the cause of Islam’ (p. 27 ).
Similarly, in the third chapter, “Womanhood in Islam”, Khan quotes
Quran 4: 1 , O Mankind, fear your Lord who created you from one soul and
created man’s mate from the same soul and demystifies the notion that
‘Eve was created from Adam’s rib’ in its explanation, saying that it is a
‘biblical explanation [Bible, Genesis, 2: 21 – 23 ], not a Quranic one’, for
there is not a single verse which supports this notion. On the contrary,
the fact is that ‘Eve was created—not from Adam himself—but from
the same species as Adam,’ as is elucidated in several verses like Quran
16: 72 ; 30: 21 ; and 42: 11, wherein the word for ‘Soul (nafs) has been used
to mean “species”’ (pp. 28 – 29 ). He summarizes this discussion aptly in
these words: ‘women and men are from the same species. Biologically
speaking, women have not been extracted from the bodies of their
male counterparts. God fashioned them according to His Will, just as
He fashioned men in accordance with His Almighty Will and Power’
(p. 30). As for sayings of the Prophet such as ‘women have been created
from a rib’ and ‘a woman is like a rib, if you try to straighten it, it will break’, he is of the opinion that these should be ‘taken metaphorically,
not literally,’ for they refer to ‘the delicacy of women’s nature’ (pp. 31 ,
33 ).
“The status of woman” is dealt with in the 4th chapter, and Khan
stresses, in unequivocal terms, that in Islam ‘a woman enjoys the
same status as that of a man”, as is evident from Quran 3: 195 , You
are members, one of another. ‘There is no difference between man and
woman as regards status, rights, and blessings both in this world and
in the Hereafter. Both are equal participants as far as the carrying out
of the functions of daily living is concerned’ (p. 38 ). He further mentions
that the ‘biological division of human beings into male and female is
the result of purposeful planning on the part of the Creator. Man and
woman in the eyes of Islam are not duplicates of one another, but the
complements’ and the ‘Islamic precepts for men and women are based
on their respective, natural constitutions’ (pp. 38 – 39 ).
Similarly, in the explanation of Quran 4: 34 , Men are the protectors and
maintainers of women, because God has made some of them to excel
others, Khan states that it is ‘an additional quality, and not a quality
of superiority’ (p. 46 ), because the Arabic word Fadilah is ‘used in the
scriptures to indicate the additional, masculine quality of protectiveness.
For a household to be properly run, it should, of necessity, have a
guardian. Guardianship is rightly entrusted to the family member who
is best qualified to undertake this responsibility—namely, the husband,
for protectiveness is a virtue which has been granted by nature in
greater measure to men than to women. Far from mentioning absolute
masculine superiority, the above-quoted verse only implies that man is
the master in the home because of the additional attributes with which
he has been endowed by nature’ (pp. 46 – 47 ).
In the 5th chapter, the author highlights the contribution of some “Muslim
Women” (pp. 49 – 78 ) in Islamic history, who have ‘played significant
roles and, by their feats, have demonstrated not only the vast arena
which Islam affords them for the performance of noble and heroic
deeds but also the exaltedness of the position accorded to women in
Islamic society’ (p. 49 ). Here he refers to Aishah who is presented as a
‘woman of notable intelligence, whose intellectual gifts were fittingly
utilized in the service of Islam’; the example of Mary, the mother of
Prophet Jesus, and Khadijah bint Khuwaylid, the Prophet’s first wife,
who are presented as ‘Two Remarkable Women’ who ‘subordinated
their own wills to that of the Almighty’ (pp. 49 , 50– 51 ). In this chapter,
he also refers to the examples of women of his own family who ‘in times of dire distress, were totally Islamic in their conduct’ (p. 70). All
this is thus mentioned to reveal that the ‘position of women in Islam...
is a matter neither of conjecture, abstract theory nor of ancient history
... [but] is a matter of actual fact’ (p. 69 ).
In the 6th chapter, the author discusses the ‘rights of the husband and
wife” (pp. 79 – 94 ) and argues that the ‘rights of men and women are not
a matter of legal lists, but rather a matter of good living’ (p. 93 ).
These are followed by a detailed discussion, in the light of Islamic
teachings and historical evidence, on concepts and issues concerning
divorce, polygamy, dowry, and hijab in Islam in chapters 7 to 10,
respectively.
The book ends with a chapter on “Success in Marriage”, in which the
author cites real-life examples. He draws these conclusions: ‘The secret
of a successful marriage is the ability to forge bonds of loyalty’ and
‘happiness in marriage is closely linked with awareness’ (p. 153 – 154 ).